Ben Gurion University
Ben
Gurion University – Israel David (Dept of Industrial Engineering) admonishes BGU administration indifference to Far Leftist incidents occurring
under the banner of "Academic Freedom"
The protests
following the Turkish flotilla incident included activists marching
outside the Ben-Gurion University senate building while giving the
Nazi salute and shouting “Heil Bibi.” These were apparently outside
provocateurs, yet members of the university’s teaching staff
participated in the demonstration. ...
Outside the university senate building we have a large poster
bearing Prime Minister Netanyahu’s image, graced with a large
“catastrophe” caption.” Anyone can come and see the display, which
originally was meant to glorify Prime Minister Ben-Gurion. The
protest expressed by about 90% of those signing the exhibit’s
guestbook have not impressed university officials, who responded by
saying this is “artistic freedom.” The management of my university
would do well to stop ridiculing itself and making people fed up
with it, and instead contemplate the complex meaning of terms such
as “academic freedom,” “freedom of speech,” “artistic freedom,” and
“artistic considerations” vis-à-vis its own simplistic perception.
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3916653,00.html
Hating Israel
on our campus
Ben-Gurion University turning into village fool, hotbed of
anti-Israel activity
Israel
David
07.07.10
The
protests following the Turkish
flotilla incident included activists marching outside the
Ben-Gurion University senate building while giving the Nazi salute
and shouting “Heil Bibi.” These were apparently outside
provocateurs, yet members of the university’s teaching staff
participated in the demonstration.
Teaching staff
members also took part in the illegal protest held on the outskirts
of campus two days earlier. Some of them have been calling for a
boycott on
Israel and characterizing it as an “apartheid state” – a term
that has been well-perceived in the global anti-Israel market.
The true role
played by Ben-Gurion University in Israeli academia’s overall
anti-Zionist activity does not justify the reputation it built in
this area. However, in recent years the university assumed the role
of village fool in the academic arena, characterized by ridiculous
displays of the abovementioned type.
However, it is
not one professor or another who are responsible for Ben-Gurion
University being perceived as second only to the Palestinian Birzeit
University in respect to anti-Israeli sentiments. Such phenomena do
not grow in a vacuum.
Let’s take the
boycott motive for example. Upon taking office, a senior university
official submitted to an interview where he pledged to take part in
leftist student protests yet shun rightist ones. In the same
interview, the official explained that one should join a boycott on
global universities “should a substantial crime take place there.”
Earlier, in January 2005, a boycott was organized against a guest
lecture by Professor Yaakov Bergman, for “fear of his influence on
young minds.” This year, ahead of the board of trustees’ session, a
donor was boycotted (in writing!) and the same happened to a
university professor.
Artistic freedom?
And what about
the Nazi circus discussed at the opening of this piece? Not too long
ago, the university dismissed a member of the appointments committee
for speaking out against the candidacy of an Israeli lecturer who
lives in the US. This candidate organized a military insubordination
campaign and compared IDF commanders and soldiers to the Nazis. The
university’s official spokesman said that “a member of the
appointments committee cannot take non-academic factors into
consideration” – a response that infuriated online readers (“And
what if it was Dr. Mengele?”)
Outside the
university senate building we have a large poster bearing
Prime Minister Netanyahu’s image, graced with a large
“catastrophe” caption.” Anyone can come and see the display, which
originally was meant to glorify Prime Minister Ben-Gurion. The
protest expressed by about 90% of those signing the exhibit’s
guestbook have not impressed university officials, who responded by
saying this is “artistic freedom.”
The management
of my university would do well to stop ridiculing itself and making
people fed up with it, and instead contemplate the complex meaning
of terms such as “academic freedom,” “freedom of speech,” “artistic
freedom,” and “artistic considerations” vis-à-vis its own simplistic
perception.
The
mathematics department includes a serving professor whose son died a
hero’s death during
Operation Cast Lead, while defending the rocket-battered
university. Would it be too much to ask university officials to
consider, alongside the glorious academic freedom for lecturers to
openly curse the IDF, the bereaved professor’s freedom not to hear
his colleagues say that his son was a “Nazi criminal?”
Israel David is a
mathematics and performance research professor at Ben-Gurion
University
|