Ben Gurion University
Ben Gurion University – Not every form of speech is
protected at BGU
His answer came from
Faye Bittker, director of BGU’s Department of Public Relations
and Media Relations, who was outraged that Prof Levitt not only
believes homosexuality is “a hindrance, defect, deficiency, and an
urge that can be treated and overcome,” but that he also refused to
apologize for his convictions. … Small wonder BGU decided
immediately, “on the basis of academic considerations alone,” to
cancel the course.
Prof Steven Plaut, who teaches economics at
the University of Haifa and heads Israel’s CampusWatch, a monitoring
organization, has been following Prof Levitt’s case. “Now if Levitt
had called for murdering all Israeli Jews or said that Jews drink
gentile blood for Passover, that would have been protected
speech,” said Prof Plaut. The Legal Forum for the Land of Israel has
taken up Prof Levitt’s case and says the next stop will be the
Supreme Court.
http://jewishvoiceandopinion.com/pdf/201007.pdf (page 5)
.http://jewishvoiceandopinion.com
Av 5769 The Jewish Voice and Opinion Page - 5
The Current Crisis:
“Even in Laughter, the Heart Can Ache”
S.L.R
July 2010
In the Democratic state of
Israel last month, Ben Gurion University fired a professor
for voicing his opinion that children raised by homosexual parents
could be harmed developmentally and that, in any case, sexual
inclinations can be restrained.
Prof Yeruham Levitt
had been teaching a course on
medical ethics for pharmacological students. Several weeks ago, the
topic was fertilization methods for homosexual couples.
A young female student
expressed concern for the development of children raised by
homosexual parents. An openly homosexual student objected to her
point. When Prof Levitt intervened, he said he, too, would be
concerned about the children, especially their ability to lead
normal family lives.
He also maintained that
sexual inclinations can be restrained.
After the class, some
students complained to the school’s administration and Prof Levitt
was summoned to a hearing. He defended himself by explaining that it
is acceptable for a lecturer to express his opinion in classes on
ethics. Nevertheless, the head of the BGU School of Pharmacology,
Prof Riad Agbariya, fired him.
Another BGU lecturer,
Dr. Neve Gordon, head of the Dept of Politics and Government,
still teaches there even though he called for a political, economic,
and academic boycott of Israel.
When BGU supporters
complained about Dr. Gordon’s presence at BGU, the school’s rector,
Prof Jimmy Weinblatt, said, “We live in a democratic country
in which there is freedom of expression for all, even for those
whose opinions are not appreciated by all.”
Arthur Goldberg,
the NJ-based founder of the group Jews Offering New Alternatives to
Homosexuality (JONAH) and the author of Light in the Closet:
Torah, Homosexuality, and the Power to Change, wrote to BGU,
expressing his concerns about the story.
His answer came from
Faye Bittker, director of BGU’s Department of Public Relations
and Media Relations, who was outraged that Prof Levitt not only
believes homosexuality is “a hindrance, defect, deficiency, and an
urge that can be treated and overcome,” but that he also refused to
apologize for his convictions.
Clarifying what he meant by
sexual restraint, Prof Levitt said he was attracted to all the
females in the class, but, he said, he contains his urges. Thus, he
told his students, people can “control themselves and overcome
defects and urges.”
According to Ms. Bittker,
with these remarks, Prof Levitt sealed his doom. Not only had he
insulted homosexuals, he had agitated the women in his class.
“The females said they
found this insulting and were hurt, and one of the females even
added that she found it difficult to sit in the class and
concentrate after these things were said,” reported Ms. Bittker.
Small wonder BGU decided
immediately, “on the basis of academic considerations alone,” to
cancel the course.
Prof Steven Plaut,
who teaches economics at the University of Haifa and heads Israel’s
CampusWatch, a monitoring organization, has been following Prof
Levitt’s case.
“Now if Levitt had called
for murdering all Israeli Jews or said that Jews drink gentile blood
for Passover, that would have been protected speech,” said
Prof Plaut.
The Legal Forum for
the Land of Israel has taken up Prof Levitt’s case and says the next
stop will be the Supreme Court. Stay tuned-and stay cool.
|