|
Home
About IsraCampus
Search
עברית
Русский
Ben Gurion U
Hebrew U
Tel Aviv U
U of Haifa
Other Schools
A-C
D-G
H-K
L-N
O-R
S-V
W-Z
Israeli Academic Extremism
Israeli Academic Extremists outside
Israel
Anti-Israel Petitions Signed by Israeli
Academics
ALEF Watch
IDI Watch
IsraCampus Essays
How to Complain
Contact Us |
Editorial Article
Sapir College - Julia Chaitin (Dept of Social Work)
Responds to Rocket Attacks by Cheerleading for the Hamas
By Lee
Kaplan,
www.IsraCampus.org.il
4/4/2011
Julia
Chaitin
grew up in Detroit and immigrated to Israel in 1972. Since then she
has lived in Kibbutz Urim, located in the Negev (desert), but
travels abroad extensively lecturing on "peace."
According to her biography and
curriculum vitae,
Chaitin received her Ph.D. in Social Psychology from Ben Gurion
University of the Negev in Beer Sheva, Israel. From 2000 - 2003, she
was head researcher at PRIME – The Peace Research Institute in the
Middle East – supposedly a jointly-run Palestinian–Israeli
non-governmental research organization. In fall 2006, she joined the
Department of Social Work at the Sapir Academic College in Israel as
a Senior Lecturer. She is also a grant writer for NISPED – The Negev
Institute for Strategies of Peace and Development.
Julia
Chaitin may be the leading pro-Hamas voice coming out of the Negev
and the embattled town of Sderot, the regular target of Hamas
rockets and bombs. She exploits her residence in the Negev to
legitimize
her
anti-Israel activism.
She
recently organized
a "Solidarity with Hamas" conference at Sapir College.
Note
this quote from a recent
article
by her:
"I live in the Negev and teach at the Sapir Academic College -- the
school located next to Sderot -- in the heart of what is called 'Qassam-land,'
after the rockets that fall on us. I know the fast beating of your
heart and the awful pit in your stomach that comes when a tzeve
adom -- red alert -- is sounded, heralding a rocket attack. I
know what it is like to comfort students and colleagues when the
rockets strike very, very close -- and to wish that someone was
there to comfort you as well. I know what it is like to be afraid to
get into the car and drive to work because you are not sure you will
make it from the parking lot to your classroom alive.
"But I know the answer to our conflict will not come with this war.
We will know peace only when we accept the fact that the
Palestinians in the Gaza Strip have every right to lives of dignity.
We will know peace only when we recognize that we must negotiate
with Hamas, our enemy, even if we are devastated that the
Palestinians did not elect a more moderate party to lead them. We
will know peace only when our leaders stop considering our lives
cheap and expendable, and help us create a beautiful, green Negev,
free of fear and despair."
Gaza is not starving, or "under siege,"
a propaganda term despite all the hype by the ISM and their flotilla
boats (Chaitin has lectured in the US at ISM affiliated churches and
groups like the Methodist Church and International Women's Peace
Service about her theories on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict). In
fact, there are luxury hotels in Gaza and people frolic at the beach
and nobody is starving.
Another quote from her about Operation
Cast Lead:
"Since the Israeli air force began bombing Gaza, it has been almost
impossible to speak openly against the war. It is difficult to find
public forums that welcome a call for a new cease-fire and for
alternative solutions to the conflict -- ones that do not rely on
military strength or a siege of Gaza. When people are in the midst
of war, they are not open to voices of peace; they speak (and
scream) out of fear and demand retribution for the harms they have
suffered. When people are in the midst of war, they forget that they
can harness higher cognitive abilities, their reason and logic.
Instead, they are driven by the hot structures of their brains,
which lead them to respond with fear and anger in ways that are
objective threats to our healthy survival. When people are in the
midst of war, voices calling for restraint, dialogue and
negotiations fall on deaf ears, if their expression is allowed at
all."
Naturally Chaitin also
supports the ISM's Gaza Flotilla boats:
"When I turned on the Israeli news at 6:40 AM on Monday morning,
knowing that the flotilla must be nearing our shores, the
broadcaster's first words were a knife to the heart: Something very
bad has happened. The commanders knew ahead of time that this was a
lose-lose situation... I could not help but wonder why the naval
commanders (and obviously the higher-ups in the government) would
knowingly go into a situation that was 'lose-lose.' I could not help
but wonder why, once again, we had thrust ourselves into an
impossible situation, endangered so many lives, perpetuated violence
and severely damaged our relations with the world community in a
nonsensical effort to enforce the unjustifiable blockade of the Gaza
Strip."
An "unjustifiable blockade" indeed.
Almost as unjustifiable as the Allied embargo of Germany in 1942.
Chaitin has also compared Israeli youth
going into the IDF with Palestinian suicide bombers. Here's a quote
from an
interview with her as the Director of PRIME:
"I talked about my decision to live there [Israel] and my life there,
again, in the context of the conflict. I continued on about how my
identity has been affected and the way I've changed over the years,
the way I look at things differently. I've been in Israel over 30
years, so I look at things differently now, then when I first came.
I more or less ended with the fact that my youngest son, at the time
he was 17, now he's eighteen, is going into the army soon. We have a
lot of discussions at home, and he wants to go into a fighting unit.
He wants to be a combat soldier. He's 18 years-old and has got
raging hormones. All of his role models, all of his friends, and the
people he looks up to are combat soldiers. Among 18-year-old boys,
that's what's discussed. I keep trying to tell him, 'Daniel, I don't
want you to go into something where you're going to be, say, in the
West Bank, pointing a gun at a Palestinian citizen.' It always ends
with, 'Oy mom, give me a break.' He's going to decide what he's
going to decide. He's 18 years old. He's an adult. It's his
decision. I was talking about how I'm torn because I love and care
about him, he's my son. Whatever he does I have to support because
how can he go into the army for at least three years and me not
support him? Then he's going to be doing things that are against my
morals, against things that I believe in. One of the Palestinians
said to me, 'Well, you just have to forbid him.' And I said, 'I
can't, what do you mean I have to forbid him, sit on him? I mean
what am I supposed to do?' And he said, 'No, if you really meant it,
then you would forbid him.' And I said, 'You know, I really mean it
and I can't forbid him, he's going to do it.'
"Then either one of the Germans or someone else from outside the
Israeli-Palestinian group said, 'Look, what if your son came to you
and said, 'I'm going to go be a suicide bomber?' What would you do?'
Cause this is also a man of peace, this Palestinian, and he said,
'Well, I would forbid him.'' And I said, 'How would you forbid him?
What would you do?' He said, 'He wouldn't do it.' I said, 'What
would you do? Would you lock him in the house? What would you do?' I
could tell that he didn't accept it. He kept asserting, 'No, I would
forbid him.' The other said, 'Okay, I believe that you would like to
forbid him just like Joy would like to forbid her son, but in the
end, your son will choose whatever path he chooses, just like her
son will choose whatever path he chooses, and that's one of the
tragedies. I mean, hopefully, neither son will choose one of these
paths, but the fact is that you live within societies where there's
also great pressure on Palestinian youth to become suicide bombers,
just like there's great pressure on Israeli youth to go into these
fighting units.' So, I think if we'd just been the Israelis and
Palestinians, that whole thing would have really blown up… So I'm
not saying we have gotten to any happy end, but on the other hand,
things could be brought up and then they were much more diffused
because it wasn't me saying it, it was somebody from the outside."
Kudos to Chaitin's son for having more common sense than his
mother! IDF soldiers like Chaitin's son are defending the Jewish
people from that annihilation.
========================================
Op-Ed articles appearing on IsraCampus.Org.il are those of the writer and
do not necessarily represent the opinion of IsraCampus.Org.il
|