Israeli Academic
Extremism
Anti-Zionist and
Post-Historians Pose an Existential Threat to Israel’s Continued
Autonomy
http://www.jewishpress.com/pageroute.do/38999
Bringing
Zionism Back To Israeli Universities
Dan
Illouz
Posted Apr 22 2009
Hamas, go ahead and bomb Sderot! With might and blood, we'll redeem
you, O Palestine!
The words above were recently chanted
by hundreds of pro-Palestinian supporters outside a university as
they waved Palestinian flags and pictures of suicide bombers in
response to a defensive Israeli military operation.
At another university, a student
received a special award in sociology, for research purporting to
conclude that since Israeli soldiers do not rape Palestinian women,
the soldiers therefore must be racist. At yet another university,
protesters vehemently objected to the appointment of a law professor
because he participated in the recent operation in Gaza as a legal
adviser to the Israel Defense Forces.
If you're thinking this sounds like
garden variety anti-Zionist sentiment of the type one expects to
hear on campuses around North America and Europe, you're sadly
mistaken. Regrettably, these incidents all took place at various
universities in Israel, and many of the protesters were Israeli
students.
In recent years, anti-Zionist trends
have been proliferating in the curricula of Israeli universities,
gradually displacing, marginalizing, and excluding Zionist discourse
and discouraging Zionist students from making their voices heard.
According to a recent study by
Im Tirzu, though more
than 70 percent of Israelis identify themselves as "strongly
Zionist," at least 80 percent of the courses offered in political
thought in Israeli universities are taught from an anti-Zionist or
post-Zionist perspective.
As Israel's new prime minister,
Benjamin Netanyahu, said in a recent interview, "Politicians,
whether they know it or not, are guided by ideas. Right now, in
Israel, they are starting to be guided with the wrong ideas." These
wrong ideas stem from the current post-Zionist discourse promulgated
in the media and academia.
Most revolutionary movements over the
past few centuries have been started by students. Even leaders such
as Ben-Gurion and Jabotinsky joined the Zionist movement and started
their lives as activists when they were still young, in their 20s.
Today, though, the majority of Zionist students on Israeli campuses
remain silent while a small but vocal minority of anti-Zionist and
post-Zionist students are taking control of the public discourse.
This creates a tragic reality as Israel's future leaders are being
inundated with anti-Zionist and post-Zionist ideas as part of the
education upon which they presumably will base their eventual
leadership.
In a country like Israel, founded on
ideals rather than mere practicality, the end of Zionism could also
mean the end of the successful endeavor of building the Jewish
state. While assimilation may work for certain western countries,
Israel presents a unique situation because Zionism is the foundation
on which the nation was constructed. If Israel is to continue to
grow, the foundational values of Zionism must be revitalized and
maintained.
As long as a reality exists in which a
professor can kick a student out of his class for coming there
straight from reserve duty without changing out of his IDF uniform,
the Zionist dream will be in danger. As long as some university
campuses can prohibit the placement of Israeli flags in celebration
of Yom Ha'atzmaut, the continued growth of Israel will be in
danger. As long as public discourse about Zionism continues to be
discouraged in the Jewish state, the ongoing process that has been
the development of Israel will be in grave danger.
In order for the State of Israel to
advance forward, we need to take action to ensure that the great
ideals that supported its creation continue to be reinforced and
re-invigorated.
Sixty years ago, Herzl spoke the famous
words that now appear to have been almost prophetic: "If you will
it, it is not a dream and if you do not will then everything I have
told you is only a dream and will continue to remain a dream."
Through strong will and hard work, the
Jewish people returned to the land of Israel after 2,000 years of
exile and regained control over its destiny. Over the past 60 years,
Herzl's words have proven true time and time again. Adherence to
this ideology is what has enabled Israel to maintain itself as the
only stable democracy in the Middle East, and it is only continued
loyalty to this ideology that will move the country toward becoming
an even more ideal and just place.
It is time to call on all followers of
this basic Zionist ideology to create yet another Zionist revolution
- a revolution to ensure that, instead of stepping backward into a
post-Zionist decline, Israel will move forward and grow into a more
virtuous, more modern, more democratic, and more Jewish state.
Only when the now-silenced majority is
once again given a voice, both on and off campus, will it be able to
speak loudly enough to drown out the noise created by the boisterous
and strident minority.
The ideals of Zionism must once again
be returned to the center of public discourse in Israel. Only then
will those ideals inspire a new generation of leaders, who will
ensure the success and growth of the Jewish state.
Dan Illouz is the overseas
communications coordinator of
Im Tirtzu and is
currently completing his law degree at Hebrew University. He can be
contacted at
tzipiyah@gmail.com.
|