Israeli Academic Extremism
The Pseudo-Academic
Shir Hever (Alternative Information Center) makes Apartheid
comparison
His 'economic lens' is
conveniently blind to suicide bombers and security concerns
The segregation of
Palestinians in the OPT is even more blatant. With most Palestinians
confined to caged communities, which they can leave only with a
special permit from Israel, surrounded by roads which they are not
allowed to travel on, and subjected daily to a humiliating and
arbitrary system of surveillance, the similarities between the life
of Palestinians in the OPT to the life of blacks under apartheid in
South Africa are even more striking than those of Palestinian
citizens.
Israeli citizens, and
especially Jewish settlers, enjoy privileges in the OPT over the
indigenous Palestinian population. As a result, the Palestinian
economy is strangled. Businesses depend on special permits from the
Israeli authorities for importing raw materials and machinery, for
transporting finished goods (not only to Israel but also within the
OPT itself). As the Palestinians have no borders, Israel controls
all of their imports and exports, and collects customs from products
intended for the OPT (customs which are often withheld by the
Israeli government). Meanwhile, Israeli businesses enjoy
unrestricted access to the Palestinian economy.
The Palestinians have
been deprived of the right to work freely, to produce, trade, and
generally to sustain themselves. In the Gaza Strip, many have thus
become dependent on international aid for food. Israel has not only
robbed them of their livelihood, but also of their dignity.
http://www.alternativenews.org/english/index.php/topics/economy-of-the-occupation/3965-economic-separation-under-israeli-control
Economic separation under Israeli control
Shir Hever, author of The
Political Economy of Israel's Occupation, examines Israeli policies
towards the Palestinians through an economic lens, arguing that
separation is a poor economic option for all parties involved
SHIR HEVER FOR THE ALTERNATIVE INFORMATION
CENTER
WEDNESDAY, 07 DECEMBER 2011
The Zionist movement
had always been a diverse movement, with different branches
promoting different approaches to the colonization of Palestine. The
biggest internal contradiction of Zionism has been the tension
between expansionism and ethnic purity, a disagreement with
widespread economic ramifications.
The Israeli political
map is dominated by Zionist parties, which agree on the concept of a
Jewish state, but they do not agree on the level by which the Jewish
state will impose restrictions on non-Jews within its bounds, or on
the final borders of that state.
Palestinian
citizens in Israel
Palestinian citizens
of Israel, currently comprising approximately 20 percent of all
Israeli citizens, were kept under military rule in the years
1948-1966. The Zionist government discouraged Jews from purchasing
products from Palestinian citizens or from employing Palestinian
citizens, and therefore the exploitation of the Palestinian's labor
was minimal. Although most of their lands were expropriated, the
people themselves were pushed out of the Israeli economy and were
forced to develop a niche economy.
The military rule was
repealed in 1966, allowing Palestinian citizens to travel freely
within Israel, but their economic marginalization continues to this
day. Their average wage is half of the wage of Jewish citizens, they
suffer from a lack of approved industrial zones, from inferior
infrastructure and lower investments in education and health.
Many Israeli
economists (including the chairman of the Central Bank of Israel)
argue that the marginalization of the Palestinian citizens is
counter-productive for the Israeli economy, and that Israel cannot
fulfill its economic potential while holding back a fifth of the
population. However, the current political environment in Israel is
becoming increasingly hostile towards Palestinian citizens, and
discrimination, intimidation and marginalization are becoming more
severe. The government continues to allocate a discriminatory budget
which contributes to growing inequality.
The Occupied
Palestinian Territories
The segregation of
Palestinians in the OPT is even more blatant. With most Palestinians
confined to caged communities, which they can leave only with a
special permit from Israel, surrounded by roads which they are not
allowed to travel on, and subjected daily to a humiliating and
arbitrary system of surveillance, the similarities between the life
of Palestinians in the OPT to the life of blacks under apartheid in
South Africa are even more striking than those of Palestinian
citizens.
Israeli citizens, and
especially Jewish settlers, enjoy privileges in the OPT over the
indigenous Palestinian population. As a result, the Palestinian
economy is strangled. Businesses depend on special permits from the
Israeli authorities for importing raw materials and machinery, for
transporting finished goods (not only to Israel but also within the
OPT itself). As the Palestinians have no borders, Israel controls
all of their imports and exports, and collects customs from products
intended for the OPT (customs which are often withheld by the
Israeli government). Meanwhile, Israeli businesses enjoy
unrestricted access to the Palestinian economy.
The Palestinians have
been deprived of the right to work freely, to produce, trade, and
generally to sustain themselves. In the Gaza Strip, many have thus
become dependent on international aid for food. Israel has not only
robbed them of their livelihood, but also of their dignity.
Warehousing
Scholars who compare
Israel's policies with the policies of Apartheid South Africa often
point out that the biggest difference between the two systems was
that blacks in South Africa were incorporated into the economic
system as the working class, and exploiting their labor was an
important aspect of the apartheid system. In Palestine, however, the
Israeli government strives for a policy of separation – in which
Palestinians are marginalized from the economic sphere.
Nowhere is this more
apparent than in the Gaza Strip, which Israel turned into the
world's biggest open-air prison. Although Israel has the ability to
exploit the Gazan economy, it instead opts to close Gaza off (at
great cost). This policy is also used in the West Bank, where the
separation barrier is creating prison-like enclaves that are
increasingly dependent on international aid.
This policy, which
Jeff Halper called "warehousing" is a policy which Israel is
exporting to other countries through technological developments that
enable a more efficient separation of "unwanted" people.
Warehousing appeals
to conservative elements around the world, who are also great
supporters of Israel. They wish to adopt Israeli policies of
warehousing and containment against labor migrants, refugees, ethnic
minorities, and, at times, even protestors.
|